Category: Q&A

1. USCIS can take any action such as issuing notices for information or denial prior to the priority date becoming current

A reader asks:
My I-485 suddenly changed to “Case Remains Pending”. What happened? I applied for EB-2 in October 2023, downgraded to EB-3, and applied for I-485 at the same time, and sent in the medical examination materials. In late November 2023, I took fingerprints, and finally waited until the end of March 2024. The I-140 downgrade was approved, but I received an RFE for the medical examination. In April, I resubmitted the medical examination materials, and the status remained at NBC for a long time. In July, the status was updated to Case Remains Pending. The PD is June 2020, and the table A is current, so why is it pending? A week after July, I received a letter from USCIS saying that the visa number is gone and the case has been transferred to NBC again. What should I do?

Alan Lee, Esq. answers,
I will assume that you are a native of China for purposes of the question. With a priority date of June 2020, and with the downgraded I-140 approved in March 2024, there was a window of time through September 2024 where final visa availability for China born was open to those who had filed labor certification applications or I-140 petitions prior to 9/1/20 to have their pending I-485 applications approved. However, the visa bulletin changed in October 2024 to reflect availability date for EB-3 China of 4/1/20. I do not know what happened with your case previously and why it was not acted upon between March-September 2024, but at this time, the visa number is no longer available, and you will have to wait until it once again becomes available to your priority date before USCIS can approve your downgraded application for adjustment of status. (I note that USCIS can take other action such as issuing notices for information or denial prior to the priority date becoming current if it decides that those actions are appropriate).

2. You are allowed to take the priority date with you if new employer successfully applies for a new labor certification and/or I-140 petition

A reader asks:
I am a PD in August 2022, and I applied for EB-2. I don’t know if the new fiscal year will make a big leap forward, whether the deadline will be met or downgraded. Now, I have an offer and can change jobs, but the new company does not have a batch, and I need to go through all the application procedures again. At present, it will take at least one and a half years to get I-140 again. The current company culture is a bit toxic. I can work until the end of the year, but it is not very stable and the career development opportunities are not very good. The new company should be good and very stable. May I ask, what should I do?

Alan Lee, Esq. answers,
I will assume that you are China born which in the month of December 2024 has EB-2 availability dates of 3/22/20 and 10/1/20 on Charts A and B of the visa bulletin. If the I-140 petition has already been approved with a priority date of August 2022 and the company has not taken steps to revoke the approval within 180 days, you are allowed to take the priority date with you if another employer successfully applies for a new labor certification and/or I-140 petition. The timeline for your final immigration would not fit within your statement that you can stay until the end of the year at your current company. Therefore, if the new company seems good and is very stable and is willing to take on your processes for permanent residence, you may certainly wish to switch to the new company.

3. A common reason for advance parole denial is if the applicant left the US prior to the time that the advance parole application was approved

A reader asks:
My I-765 was approved on July 25, and I-131 was approved on July 27, which should be a combo. However, on July 29, I-131 became reopened. What does this mean? Was it approved or not? What is the reason for reopening?

Alan Lee, Esq. answers,
It is in the discretion of USCIS whether to issue a combo card or not. If you have a combo card, the travel privilege will be indicated on the bottom of the EAD. In such case, it would be unusual for USCIS to reopen a request for advance parole once it is approved. USCIS can generally reopen an adjudication if there is new evidence indicating that the benefit should not have been given. A common reason for advance parole denial or revocation is if the applicant left the US prior to the time that the advance parole application was approved.

4. Many factors are taken into account, and a $20,000 decrease is a factor to be looked at

A reader asks:
I have submitted my I-485 and recently received an offer base that is 20,000 yuan less than the base of the old company. I would like to ask, if I accept the offer and submit I-485J through the new company, and the salary is 20,000 less than the old company, will it affect the approval of I-485?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
You would be relying upon a transfer of your case under I-485 J, which allows the labor certification and I-140 petition to remain valid if the I-140 petition is approved and the I-485 application pending 180 days, and the new job is in the same or similar occupation. Many factors are taken into account including job duties, SOC codes, job title, of which a $20,000 decrease is a factor to be looked at. It should be noted that $20,000 less when an individual is making a salary of $150,000 is less concerning than when the individual is making $50,000 or so under the labor certification.

5. On EB-1A case, a magazine is asking you for money in order to interview you is not something that most recognized magazines would do.

A reader asks:
I am a computer professor at a 985 university in China. I am preparing to apply for EB-1A and am preparing the materials. An editor of a scientific magazine in China wants to interview me, but charges 20,000 to 30,000 RMB. This magazine is considered a national magazine. I don’t know if this is useful for my EB-1A application? Is this considered media coverage?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
The regulations on media state that it must be published material about you in a professional or major trade publications or other major media relating to your work in the field for which classification is sought. USCIS generally looks to see a magazine circulation compared to other magazines in the field and who is the intended audience of the publication. The fact that the magazine is asking you for money in order to interview you is not something that most recognized magazines would do. You may want to further look into the bona fides of the scientific magazine to determine whether it is truly a respected publication in China. A big boost in whether it would really convince USCIS is if it has international renown.

6. USCIS is asking for separate checks for each of the benefits that you are requesting

A reader asks:
I submitted I-485, I-131 and I-765 two months ago. So far, the lawyer has replied that only the signature of FedEx has been received. It has been almost 2 months, and the check has not been cashed. Is this normal?

Alan Lee, Esq. answers,
It is slightly unusual that USCIS has not receipted your applications and it has been almost 2 months. It is not unheard of, however. Is there a chance that USCIS is getting ready to reject and return your applications? Possibly. Other than through the check not having been cashed, your attorney could have received indication from USCIS of an acceptance if he or she possibly sent in G-1145 E-Notification of Application/Petition Acceptance with your package. I also note that you mention “check” and you and your attorney should know that USCIS is asking for separate checks for each of the benefits that you are requesting.

1. USCIS will generally not deem your I-485 application abandoned if you depart the United States and return on a valid H-1B visa. 

A reader asks:
I submitted my I-485, I-131, and I-765, but they haven’t been approved yet. I initially thought leaving the country would only mean forfeiting the I-131 and I planned to return to the U.S. on my H-1B visa. However, I later realized that if I don’t have a combo card, my case will be rejected if I’m abroad with the I-485 being processed. Is this true? My question is, can I leave the country six months after submitting the I-485?

Arthur Lee Esq. Answers:
If you are in valid H-1B status with a valid visa in your passport, USCIS will generally not deem your I-485 application abandoned if you depart the United States and return on the H-1B visa. Assuming that your H-1B visa and status will still be valid 6 months from now, and that you will still be in the same job which conferred you H-1B status, USCIS will not likely deny your I-485 due to your travel outside the United States. To minimize your risk of being denied entry on your H-1B visa, you should bring your official H-1B approval as well as sufficient evidence that you are still in your H-1B job being paid at least the salary stated on your company’s I-129 petition on your behalf. Such evidence may include but is not limited to a job letter by the company verifying your position title and salary, and recent paystubs from your employer.

2. A Porting Determination

A reader asks:
I applied for EB-3, had my green card interview in October 2023, but it has been stuck at “Interview Completed, Under Case Review” until now (October 2024). I emailed the immigration office, and their response was that my case is still within the normal processing time. I’ve already submitted my I-485 and received a new offer, but the base salary is $20,000 less than my old company. If i take this new job and submit a new I-485J with the new company, will the lower salary affect my case?

Arthur Lee Esq. Answers:
Under job porting, you are allowed to take a position that is in the “same or similar” occupational category as your position that is the basis of your I-140 petition. After you submit your I-485J (which can be submitted in response to an RFE, at an adjustment of status interview, or proactively if you wish), USCIS will take a myriad of factors into account to determine whether your position is “same or similar” to the one that is the basis of your I-140 approval. These factors include but are not limited to the DOL assigned occupational code for the new position; the job title; job duties; required skills and expertise; educational and training requirements; licenses or certifications typically required; offered wage or salary; and any other credible evidence submitted that demonstrates that the position is in the “same or similar” job classification. USCIS understands that sometimes employees find themselves in situations (such as being laid off or feeling disgruntled in a place they work) where they must make lateral moves or even take lower salaries. So in your situation, the lower wage is a negative factor. However, that may not be fatal in a porting determination if on balance, the rest of the listed factors demonstrate that your job is in a “same or similar” job occupation.

It is not advisable to file an H-1B transfer to a new position until after you have an I-485 application pending for at least 180 days

A reader asks:
I submitted a PERM application in January 2024, and based on my current processing times, I expect it to be approved around February or March 2025. I plan to have my lawyer immediately submit the I-140 after PERM approval with premium processing. I predict that I will receive I-140 approval around March or April 2025. If I want to switch to a new company immediately after getting I-140 approval, based on this timeline, should I first have my current employer file an H-1B extension, or if I find a new employer before the end of June (my initial 3 year H-1B expires in June 2025), should I have the new employer file the H-1B extension? Should I have the old employer file the extension then switch employer after 180 days?
Arthur Lee, Esq. Answers:
My general recommendation would be to have your current employer file an H-1B extension on your behalf. Job porting only works if you have an I-485 application that has been pending for at least 180 days and you work in a position that is in a same or similar occupational classification that is the basis of your I-140 approval. If you have your I-140 petition approved, then switch to a new job immediately without having an I-485 application filed and pending for at least 180 days, then your PERM ETA 9089 and your I-140 approvals will not be valid for your I-485 application. You will not be able to port in this case. If you do move to a new position, then you will need to start the PERM process over. The only thing that you might retain is your priority date assuming that your soon-to-be previous employer has not timely revoked your I-140. Unless your employer is still willing to offer you the I-140 position upon your I-485 approval (which seems unlikely in this case), you would need to have your new employer start over from scratch in the PERM process. Therefore, it is not advisable to file an H-1B transfer to a new position until after you have an I-485 application pending for at least 180 days based upon an approved or pending I-140.

1. Working while the I-765 application is pending is unlawful

A reader asks:
I applied for EB-1A, but my I-485 was rejected because I did not have a work permit for more than 180 days. However, I did not work when I did not have a work permit. How can I prove that I did not work illegally?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
The question that I have is whether your I-485 was denied for not having a legal status for more than 180 days or for working unlawfully for more than 180 days. Having or not having a legal status is fairly cut and dried just by looking at your status papers, while the question of unauthorized employment may not be. For that, the facts count. What does the I-485 application say insofar as your employment for the past five years is concerned? Are you aware that you are only allowed to work with specific authorization even after filing the I-485 adjustment of status application? The filing of the I-485 itself does not give work authorization. In such case, many individuals file for an I-765 employment authorization application along with the I-485 and wait until it is approved before working. Working while the I-765 application is pending is unlawful unless an individual has some other basis to be employed. Was there an immigration interview and did you admit to the USCIS officer that you worked illegally? If you believe after reading the above that the decision was incorrect, you can file for a motion to have the decision reopened and reconsidered within 30 days of the decision and send in whatever proof that you may have of not having worked illegally including possibly affidavits from yourself, from your employer (if you have one) along with copies of all your pay statements showing that you did not work during the contested time.

2. A one-year extension can be requested where the labor certification application has been pending at least 365 days

A reader asks:
My second H-1B will expire in late August next year. Due to personal reasons, my lawyer just helped me file a PERM application in May this year. Considering the current timeline, is it too late for me? What other options do I have before my H-1B expires next year?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
It is currently taking approximately 11-12 months for the Department of Labor to reach a PERM labor certification application after filing. If the ETA 9089 was filed in May, the chances are that it will be reached for adjudication by August. Even if it is still pending by the end of your H-1B status in August 2025, you and your sponsoring organization remain eligible to file a H-1B extension petition under the rule that a one-year extension can be requested where the labor certification application has been pending at least 365 days. As it is not too late for you under the above circumstances, there does not appear to be a need to discuss any other options.

3. Waiting quietly and hoping to get the green card without doing anything else when the company closes may cause problems down the road

A reader asks:
My lawyer is helping me apply for an expedited I-140, and he said that I can probably file an I-485 next month. However, my company is running low on money, and it will close in six months. My boss said that I have to pay for the I-485 myself. I calculated that my wife and I will have to pay for various miscellaneous expenses. What I am thinking is that if I file now and the company goes bankrupt, my boss will definitely not be in the mood to notify USCIS that the company is no longer viable (he doesn’t even know that there is such a thing). Assuming that I don’t encounter an RFE or an interview, can I quietly wait for the green card without leaving the United States? What is the probability of not encountering an RFE and an interview? If I look for a job now, it’s not that I can’t find one, but I have to start the green card process again from PERM. Should I pay this money?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
It appears that your lawyer is trying to do everything that he or she can to have your permanent residence approved before your company closes. If the I-140 immigrant visa petition is approved, the I-485 adjustment of status application is filed, and 180 days have passed, your lawyer can attempt to port your case to another employer if you can find one which can offer you a position in the same or similar occupation. I do not know the probability of your having an RFE and interview if the company closes and you do nothing except hope that USCIS will just send you the green card. The matter of whether to pay the I-485 application fees by yourselves is a decision that you will have to make yourself. Please note that the strategy of waiting quietly and hoping to get the green card without doing anything else when the company closes may cause problems for you down the road, especially if you attempt to become a US citizen and must encounter a USCIS officer at interview at that time.

4. When USCIS issued the green card by mistake, it is recommended that your attorney to take care of the situation

A reader asks:
It has been a month since I received my green card. Then I received an interview notice last week, and the online status returned to “case was interviewed”. What should I do? The lawyer said that he received a response from USCIS, saying that there was an error in the interview appointment. I am worried that the Immigration Bureau will count my case as a no show and deny my case. Please ask, should this be okay?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
Although rare, we have seen and in fact had a case in which USCIS approved our client’s permanent residence, and then sent out an interview notice. We quickly resolved that with USCIS and assume that your lawyer will do the same, especially if he is informing you that USCIS already responded saying that there was an interview appointment error. I suggest that you allow your attorney to take care of the situation as he or she appears to be on top of it from what you say in your question.

1. To apply for EB-1A, 3 of the 10 criteria must be met

A reader asks:
I have a friend in China who has talked to me about immigration many times. He is 42 years old and is an associate professor of computer science at a 211 university in China (the school should be ranked in the top 50 in the country). He is a cadre in the system, which should be a lifetime system. His annual after-tax income is about 150,000 RMB, plus other five social insurances and one housing fund, about 230,000 RMB. He wants to apply for EB-1A to come to the United States to work as a programmer or other computer-related work. As long as his annual income covers family expenses and he can save 30,000 US dollars, he will be satisfied. He is not a member of the Communist Party. May I ask how long it will take for him to apply for first priority?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
In your fact situation, your friend is an associate professor of computer science who has good income, wants to apply for EB-1A to come to the US to work as a programmer or other computer related work, and he will be satisfied if his annual income covers family expenses and he can save $30,000 USD. He would not appear to fit within the criteria of EB1A which requires that an applicant have qualifications in 3 of 10 evidence categories to be considered, and if qualifying on 3, is then considered in a merits determination in which USCIS attempts to determine whether he or she has demonstrated national or international acclaim and that his or her achievements have been recognized in the field of expertise, indicating that he or she is one of that small percentage who has risen to the very top of the field of endeavor. USCIS considers among other criteria whether the applicant has a major award such as the Nobel Prize, or if not three other criteria such as lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes; membership in associations which require outstanding achievements of members, published material about him or her in professional or major trade publications or other major media; participation as a judge of the work of others in the field; proof of original scientific contributions of major significance in the field; and of the applicant’s authorship of scholarly articles in the field in professional or major trade publications or other major media. Your friend may decide to explore other parts of the US immigration scheme, including temporary worker under H-1B specialized occupation visa or labor certification green card – both of which require a US sponsoring employer.

1. Fing a premium processing for an EB-1 case where you are not sure about the merits of your EB-1 case is not advised  

A reader asks:
Considering that Trump’s coming to power is a high probability event, I am a little anxious about my identity issue and am hesitating whether to expedite the EB-1B. The point of hesitation is that my EB-1B case is extremely weak, and I heard that expediting will increase the possibility of rejection. Before, the NIW was approved by TSC. When applying for EB-1B, I changed jobs and moved to NSC territory. I consulted an outside lawyer, who said that the EB-1B case has a chance in TSC, but not in NSC. But since the company lawyer agreed to do it, I must give it a try. I submitted it in early May this year, but it was not expedited when I submitted it, and I did not argue. In early June, the case status was updated from received to being actively reviewed. According to the timeline of about half a year, I-140 will not receive a reply from USCIS following opinions: 1. How long is the current TSC EB-1B case timeline? Is it still half a year? 2. In my case, should the EB-1B case be expedited?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
Per the USCIS website, Texas Service Center is adjudicating 80% of EB-1B cases within 10 months. It may be a good sign in terms of speed of your case that your case status changed to “active review” in June. My suggestion is to stay patient regarding your EB-1B case. I would advise against premium processing for an EB-1 case where you are not sure about the merits of your case. Premium processing service, for whatever reason in recent years, has been known to invite tougher scrutiny in many types of immigration cases—EB-1 included. Anecdotally, many immigration lawyers in recent years have encountered difficult RFEs and NOIDs when filing premium processing for EB-1 cases—even strong cases. Also, I note that your lawyer’s belief that your case has a shot at TSC but not at NSC is very speculative. This may or may not be true, and it is difficult to determine at any given moment which service center is more likely to have tougher adjudicating officers and which ones have more lenient officers. Finally, a Trump presidency would be generally bad for intending immigrants to the US. But EB-1 was not a focus of the previous Trump administration, and will not likely be a focus of scrutiny in an upcoming Trump term. The risks toward your EB-1B petition of filing premium processing, in my belief, far outweigh the risks of a Trump presidency.

2. In filing the PERM application, you will not need to submit your resume for Department of Labor review

A reader asks:
Recently, the company wants to apply for perm, and I need to provide a resume. I have 2 questions: 1. I worked in China for 6 years before and came to the US again. Is it necessary to provide domestic experience? 2. Will the domestic experience be checked? Because the company I used to work for went bankrupt, the company should be deregistered.

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
In filing the PERM application, you will not need to submit your resume for Department of Labor review. The resume is likely for the company or company lawyer to help formulate case strategy. There is no need to provide your 6 years working experience in your PERM ETA 9089 application unless that 6 years experience is relevant to your qualifications for your sponsoring company’s position. You only need to disclose your current employment, and other employment relevant to your qualifications for the PERM position. If your experience in China for 6 years was relevant, then you may want to list that experience on the PERM ETA 9089, and obtain an experience verification letter from your China employer. This letter can come from your former manager or human resources, or anybody else you worked with in a responsible position who can attest to your experience. If the company is deregistered and out of business, you can still verify this experience by having a former manager or colleague attest to your experience while explaining that the company is now out of business. You may supplement that letter with an affidavit of your own explaining that you had worked in that position with the China company, but could not get a verification on the company’s official stationery because they went out of business.

3. When the time for processing at the field office has passed, you may wish to speak to a USCIS contact center

A Reader asks:
I applied for EB-1A, and my I-485 has been under for nearly two years. I am anxious again this year, so I have to ask Emma. I don’t understand the reply, please help me interpret it. My I-485 has been transferred to the local FO for a year and a half, and it has been current and stuck in the fingerprint status.

Q: My priority date has arrived, why is it not approved?

Q: Even if your priority date has arrived, if there are not enough visas, your case will still be suspended according to regulations until a visa is available.

Q: So even if I am in the field office now, I don’t have an EB1A visa? Is this what you mean?

A: Your case will continue to be suspended until the officer provides you with a visa number.

Excuse me, why have you not had a visa for almost two years, and shouldn’t there be a lot of EB-1A quotas in the new fiscal year (these two years)? As I said recently, I found that Emma is indeed unreliable. A month later, I asked Emma where my case was. Emma said it was at NBC. I confirmed it again and she said it had always been there, and it had never changed. I thought I had finally been transferred back to NBC from FO. I confirmed it again. She said it had been at FO for a year and a half. Did it just get transferred back? Emma immediately changed her words. Sorry, I misread the document. It was still at FO. It had been a year and a half and it was still at FO.

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
for the month of September 2024, the final action date for the EB-1A category is current for most of the world except for natives of China and India whose I-485’s cannot be approved unless their priority dates are earlier than November 1, 2022 and February 1, 2022 respectively. I note that the EB-1A category has backlogged periodically with those two countries in the past, and so you may wish to check your priority date to see if it is now current if you are a native of one of these two. Assuming that the priority date is current, and assuming that the time for processing at the field office has passed, you may wish to speak to a USCIS contact center representative at 1-800-375-5283 to see whether you can obtain more accurate information on the progress of your case.

1. If your priority date is current, it is best to file your I-485 ASAP

A reader asks:
Because the company wants to save money or not occupy the H-1B quota, the company wants me to wait as long as possible to get the combo card. My situation is to wait for the scheduled update in September this year to submit I-485 and wait for the combo card. My H-1B expires at the end of September this year. I have two options. Option one is to suspend work until you get the combo card and then continue working. Option two is to apply for an H-1B extension in September. It is estimated that it will take more than half a year to get the combo card approved. It is estimated that the combo card will be activated again in march or April when the combo is released. If H-1B is denied, company checks will not be cashed. I also know that the best solution is to extend the H-1B immediately, but the company wants me to wait. If you think it’s best to apply for H-1B extension first, when is the deadline?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
Your deadline to file an H-1B extension would be the date of your H-1B expiration. For instance, if your H-1B status expires on September 30, 2024, your H-1B extension must be received by USCIS on or before September 30, 2024. So long as you properly file your H-1B extension, you will be authorized to work while your H-1B extension is pending adjudication for up to 240 days (typically an H-1B extension takes USCIS 2-4 months to adjudicate). If your company chooses not to file an H-1B extension on your behalf, your best alternative is to file your I-485 and I-765 concurrently as soon as possible. I am unclear as to why you are waiting until September to file your I-485 and I-765 application if your priority date is current. These applications are generally specific to you, and require limited employer participation. I do not understand why your employer would want you to wait as long as possible to receive an EAD too–that is an employment authorization card that would allow you to work for any employer (it is generally in your best interests to work for your sponsoring I-140 employer for a successful I-485 adjudication). As long as your priority date is current, it is best to file your I-485 and I-765 applications ASAP to have flexible work authorization as soon as possible, and to apply before visa retrogression potentially prevents you from filing your case. If your employer does not choose to extend your H-1B, you will not be authorized to work until your I-765 application is approved, but you will have authorization to remain in the US upon filing your I-485. In sum, it is in your best interests to take these actions as soon as possible: (1) file your I-485 as soon as your priority date becomes current, and I-765 if your employer seems unwilling to file your H-1B extension; (2) file your H-1B extension paperwork before your deadline in September.

2. Before filing I-485 you should maintain legal status

A reader asks:
The PD for my immigration application is early 2021. I later changed jobs and had my previous PERM and I-140, but it is now difficult to successfully advertise in the market. If the schedule is up but the PERM has not come down yet, will the PD expire after one year? I heard that I have to file my I-485 one year after PD current.

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
You should not lose your priority date for adjustment of status purposes through an employment-based petition unless your I-140 is revoked for fraud or misrepresentation by your employer less than 180 days after I-140 approval. Unlike consular processing where you would typically need to file your green card application (DS-260) within one year of NVC notifying you of your priority date becoming current, there is no such regulation regarding I-485 filing. Therefore, you will not likely need to worry about your priority date becoming current for more than 1 year. You just need to ensure that your priority date can be legally retained, and that you will be able to maintain legal status in the US up until the time you file your I-485 application. Good luck to you on your PERM recruitment and adjudication, and the rest of your process. As soon as your PERM ETA 9089 is certified, you should be able to concurrently file a new I-140 / I-485 with a request to retain your old priority date–as long as the visa availability does not retrogress past your old priority date and you have been maintaining legal status.

3. If your I-485 case is past standard processing times, you may wish to contact USCIS

I applied for EB-1, PD is August 2022, but the current cutoff date is already November 2022. My current I-485 status is pending fingerprints taken for half a year. However, USCIS insists that my cut-off date has not been met. What should I do?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
If your priority date has already been reached on “Chart A- Final Action Dates,” your case should be in line to be adjudicated by USCIS. However, you may wish to check standard processing times with respect to your adjudicating field office or service center. If your I-485 case is also past standard processing times, then you may wish to contact USCIS via eRequest or the Contact Center at 1-800-375-5283. If you had received communication from USCIS that your priority date is not yet available, you can reach out to them again and explain that their answer was wrong and ask for another update. USCIS officers do make mistakes in their responses to service requests, so the best thing to do is to continue to follow up until a decision is made, as long as your case is past standard processing times. Best of luck to you.

4. Going to school on a visitor visa bars a change of status application

My EB-1A was approved, Form B has arrived, and I will bring my child to the country in January with a B visa. We originally planned to submit the I-485 in three months, but now Form B is closed. The child has enrolled in a local public school. The school will have a holiday at the end of May and start school in August. My B visa expires at the end of June. Can the children continue to go to school smoothly here?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
If your child is on a B visa, he or she is not allowed to go to school. Going to school on a visitor visa bars a change of status application if USCIS knows of it. Also note that schooling is not allowed until a change of status application is approved. Current published USCIS processing times indicate that 80% of F-1 change of status applications take approximately 4.5 months to reach for adjudication. You may wish to rethink your strategy.

5. It is best to wait until you have your H-1B approval before you leave the U.S. 

A reader asks:
My I-485 application is pending, H-1B will expire in less than a month, and the H-1B extension has been submitted but has not been approved yet. I have a Canadian visa. If I go to Canada to visit, can I get H-1B to return to the US? What are the risks?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
If you go to Canada, you will not likely be able to return to the US until your H-1B extension is approved. CBP cannot grant you a new time on an entry that you do not have approval for. It may allow you entry for the balance of time on your present H-1B if you attempt reentry during your present H-1B validity, but not the time afterwards which is not yet approved. In the latter scenario, it is likely that CBP will refuse you at the border and tell you to reattempt entry once you have your H-1B extension approved. Therefore, if you plan to return after H-1B expiration, it is best to wait until you have your H-1B approval before you go to Canada, unless you are truly willing to wait in Canada until your H-1B is approved before making the trip back over Stateside.

6. H-1B has not submitted I-140, the spouse cannot work with H-4.

H-4 has a NIW PD, can I work? But if I submitted an I-140 before marriage, the principal applicant does not have an H-1B, and the partner has an H-1B, but did not submit an I-140 together, in this case, can the principal applicant use the H-4 to work? If the I-140 is submitted together, will there be any difference?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
From your question, my understanding is that you, the principal applicant, submitted an I-140 prior to getting married to your spouse; your spouse has H-1B status, but did not submit an I-140 petition. In this case, you would not likely be able to work on your H-4 status. An H-4 EAD is only conferred to the spouse of an H-1B principal who has an approved I-140, or who has been granted H-1B extension under sections 106(a) or (b) of the AC21. The first condition of your spouse having an approved I-140 is clearly not met. The second condition may be met if your spouse received an H-1B extension past the sixth year due to having a PERM labor certification approved for 365 days or more. If the second condition is met, then you may be able to file for an EAD through a properly filed I-765 application based upon your H-4 status. It does not make a big difference in the H-4 EAD context whether you listed your spouse as a family member in your I-140 petition. You will just need to show that you have an approved I-539 as the H-4 dependent, and give in appropriate documentation of the above described condition relating to your spouse and your marriage in your I-765 application.

1. If the consular officer or USCIS finds you improperly shared technical knowledge, it may be a ground for denial of your visa or green card. 

A reader asks:
Recently, a domestic headhunter and a friend who is starting a business contacted me and suggested that I apply for a national or provincial talent program. If approved, it will be 500,000 RMB per year, and a total of 1.5 million RMB for 3 years. I would like to ask, if applying for such a program will affect the future green card 485 change of status?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
If you take up a position with a national/provincial talent program, your future green card application and your application for a visa at the consulate may face tougher scrutiny given the political climate between the US and China at this time. The US government has been cracking down on foreign talent recruitment programs, which it believes are a mechanism used by foreign countries such as China to bring outside knowledge and innovation back to their countries, including stealing trade secrets, breaking export control laws, or violating conflict-of-interest policies to do so. The FBI notes that while various countries use talent plans, China is the most prolific sponsor of these programs. Therefore, if you work at a talent program, your applications to come to the US on a visa, or adjust status to I-485 may be subject to further investigation into the questions of whether you have improperly exported technical knowledge and trade secrets to China. You will need to be prepared to answer questions about whether you have ever utilized or shared knowledge regarding sensitive US technology secrets and innovations during your time working at the talent program. If the consular officer or USCIS finds that you more likely than not have improperly shared knowledge with the talent program, that may be a ground for denial of your visa or green card application.

2. NVC may choose to wait on the fee bill until your priority date is about to become current

A reader asks:
I applied for NIW and submitted it at the beginning of this year. I applied for expedited application two months later and was approved early March. How long will it take to receive the NVC payment notice? Online status check shows that the case has been transferred to NVC.

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
Congratulations on your NIW approval. After your I-140 is approved, your case is sent to NVC assuming that you chose consular processing as your means of applying for permanent residence. USCIS notifies NVC that your case has been approved, and instructs it to pre-process you for your permanent residence application through consular processing. Typically, NVC will first send you a welcome notice then contact you with a fee bill within 60 days of your petition approval. But if you are from a country with a long backlog, NVC may choose to wait on the fee bill until your priority date is about to become current. Therefore, if you have not received any communication from NVC, and your priority date is current or about to become current (per the “Date of Filing” chart), you may wish to follow up with NVC.

1. If I-485 is current and past processing times, you can place a service request online

A reader asks，
In September 2021, the I-485 I submitted was EB-1B and the PD has been current. At present, it has been two years since the approval, and it is still pending. The lawyer said that currently approval is usually within one year. Can I urge USCIS to take a look at the case?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
Processing times for employment-based I-485 cases are different in each local field office and jurisdiction. You should ascertain which local field office or service center is adjudicating your I-485, and then look up the processing times here: https://egov.uscis.gov/processing-times/. I note that in many jurisdictions, including New York City, an employment-based I-485 filed in September 2021 would be past processing times. While there is no way to “urge” USCIS to look at your adjustment of status case, there are mechanisms to check your case.  As your case is past standard processing times, you can place a service request at https://egov.uscis.gov/e-request/Intro.do. Here, you may select “past processing times” and enter in the information on your case and inquire on its status. Although USCIS does not provide time estimates for responses on these types of requests anymore, you can likely expect a response within 30 days, hopefully of some substance. Another alternative is to call the USCIS “contact center” at 1-800-375-5283 to gather status updates on your case and inquire on what progress a USCIS “agent” sees on your case. The USCIS agent may also request that your officer look at your case (same effect as placing a service request online). It is important to keep your records of your service requests and your communications with “contact center” officers; if these requests are unsuccessful or yield unsatisfactory responses, you may do an ombudsman request, in which a DHS ombudsman staff member requests that USCIS looks into your case. Best of luck to you.

2. A request for reconsideration must come within 30 days of the denial

A reader asks,
Today I learned that PERM did not have an audit and was directly rejected. The reason was that one of the skills did not appear in the experience letter of the previous company. It’s an oversight on the part of the lawyer. Now, lawyers suggest reconsidering and re-filing together. Is there a high chance of reconsideration? It’s not that I don’t want to file again. I really don’t know if I can convince my boss to apply for me again in this situation.

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
I note that it is not common practice for attorneys to upload prior experience letters to ETA 9089 to the Department of Labor. Signed prior experience letters are typically reserved for the I-140 stage after the ETA 9089 is certified. Based upon your question, I assume that your facts are correct and if that is the case, your attorney prepared the relevant prior experience sections incorrectly in having requirements in your PERM job that were not met by your prior experience, education, or training. Specifically, it seems based off your description that your attorney failed to mention one of your skills in your prior experience summary that was one of the job requirements. In such a case, you may have significant trouble succeeding on a request for reconsideration as such does not allow additional evidence that was not originally filed with the ETA 9089. A request for review at BALCA also does not allow additional evidence. Therefore, unless your attorney’s description of your “skill” in your prior experience and the “skill” required in your PERM position are arguably a match and/or open for interpretation and you can meet the burden of proof in demonstrating that your adjudicator erred in his/her decision, your chances of winning a request for reconsideration appear to be low. Please note that a request for reconsideration must come within 30 days of the denial, and a review by BALCA must also come within 30 days of a denial by DOL or affirmation of the denial on reconsideration.

3. You may request a duplicate receipt on eRequest if you did not receive one

A reader asks: 
I am an EB-2 green card applicant. The application documents for the primary and secondary cards sent by UPS to the lockbox in Chicago in April showed that they had been signed for that month, but so far I have not received the receipt, and the check has not been cashed. I want to ask, is this normal? How long after delivery should I receive the receipt?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
Typically after a month, the check(s) will have been cashed and you would have received a filing receipt. You may wish to check whether your filing was sent to the correct address. Please note that filing addresses are different due to a myriad of factors including whether you are filing a standalone I-485; whether you have other applications such as I-765 and I-131 filed concurrently with it; I-485 category, etc. If you have filed your application to the correct address, but have not yet received a receipt, you may wish to call the USCIS contact center and try to locate your file by informing the officer of your “A” number if you have one. If you get a receipt number, that solves the issue, and you may request a duplicate receipt on eRequest if you did not receive one. If USCIS does not have a receipt for your case (which is likely because your check has not been cashed), you can email lockbox support at lockboxsupport@uscis.dhs.gov. In this email, you should include your name, “A” number if you have one, address, telephone number, and how you paid your filing fee. Please explain in your letter that you have sent your case to this lockbox, and it has been delivered and signed for, but that your case has not been receipted yet nor checks cashed. Hopefully through assistance by Lockbox Support USCIS will locate your case. If all else fails, you can refile your case assuming you have kept copies of all evidence–just issue a new payment. If your payment with your initial submission is checked, then contact the bank and cancel your second payment. Best of luck to you.

4.  You can use an approved EB-2’s priority date to apply for another employment based petition

A reader asks,
Since EB-1 also has a waiting period now, if I apply for EB-1 while I already have an EB-2 PD, will my PD be re-established or will the PD of the newly applied EB-1 be the same as the original EB-2 PD? If it is not the original EB-2 PD, will the application be invalidated?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
I will assume that the EB-2 petition has already been approved. If so, and there are no applicable grounds for revocation, you can use the priority date for purposes of applying for another employment based petition, including EB-1. As your EB-1 case is now scheduled, I assume that you have already filed form I-485. Generally to accord an earlier priority date, you would request that the earlier priority date be assigned when you file the new I-140 petition. If you did not, hopefully the officer at the interview will allow for the transfer of priority date. If not and the EB-1 petition was filed without a current priority date, there would be a problem. If filed with a current EB-1 priority date and the date has retrogressed, the I-485 filing would still be valid although you might have to wait for the EB-1 date to again become current again before the officer can make a final adjudication on your case.

5. A NIW petition may affect the renewal of F-1 to return to the United States

A reader asks:
I am in my first year of postdoc OPT, studying for a PhD in the United States, and my current student visa F-1 has expired. I plan to apply for NIW and will it affect my return to the United States after returning to my country? Because F-1 is a non-immigrant visa and applying for NIW has immigration intent, will it affect the renewal of F-1 to return to the United States?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
As you note, a F-1 visa is one requiring nonimmigrant intent. A NIW petition on form I-140 is an immigrant visa petition, a contrary concept. You may have problems renewing the F-1 visa since one of the questions on the DS-160 application form for a nonimmigrant visa is “Has anyone ever filed an immigrant petition on your behalf with the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)? If YES, explain.” It may increase your chances of visa renewal to apply for the NIW petition after returning to the US.

1. After being fired and H-1B grace period is up, you can try to return to school to maintain nonimmigrant status

A reader asks:
The first time I applied for PERM in 2020, I was audited and I submitted supplementary materials. In early 2022, I was notified that it was rejected. The reason for rejection was that the recruitment advertisement did not comply with regulations. In mid-2022, the company was acquired, and the new company ran a second PERM and encountered a hiring freeze. After waiting for 6 months, I submitted the second PERM application in October 2023. However, I was suddenly fired last month and the PERM is still being processed. It is now the 6th year of H1-B and is valid until November. I have interviewed with several companies lately, but after chatting with HR, I was rejected. Some companies require to have I-140 in the 6th year. Some said that the company does not apply for PERM this year. They also contacted the company where I was fired. After the first round of interviews, they arranged for a second round of interviews next week. The result was two days before the interview. HR called and said role restructure, and the interview was canceled. I want to apply for NIW, but I only have a Master’s degree in CS from the US + work experience as a coder. I have not published any papers or participated in academic conferences. There are only more than 30 days left in the 60 day grace period, and I feel like I can no longer find a job due to status issues. What should we do in this situation now?

Arthur Lee, Esq. answers,
Based upon your summary of your education and work experience along with your lack of published papers and academic conferences, I do not believe that you would be eligible for EB-2 NIW. Unfortunately, your pending PERM will no longer be valid since your company laid you off (unless they agree to continue to sponsor you with a promise of having the position ready for you at the agreed wage upon your green card approval). Therefore, you would likely need to start over and find another company to agree to sponsor you from the beginning of the PERM process.
As you only have 30 days left in your 60 day grace period, you will need to either find a way to maintain your nonimmigrant status or leave the United States. To maintain your nonimmigrant status, you may try to find a company to hire you on your 6th year of H-1B, although this may pose a challenge to both you and the company since you would be capped at working for until November, and then you will need to find ways to maintain valid working status or stop working and go back to school, or leave the US. If you leave the US for a year, your 6 year H-1B allowance would reset, but you would need to win the cap lottery again or find a cap exempt employer to be eligible to work in the US. If you are lucky enough to find employment overseas with a multinational company with a branch or affiliate in the US, and you work in a year in an executive, managerial, or specialized knowledge capacity, then the company can transfer you to the US to work in its related company under L-1 status for 5 or 7 years.
Other ways of maintaining your nonimmigrant status include going back to school and changing your status to F-1 for the duration of your education, or changing your status to a “B” visitor, during which you may interview for future jobs. Best of luck to you.

2. Although the new job salary is $20,000 less than before, those I-485 applicants with higher salaries will not be affected 

A reader asks:
I have submitted my I-485 and recently received an offer base that is $20,000 yuan less than the base of the old company. I would like to ask, if I accept the offer and submit I-485J through the new company, and the salary is $20,000 less than the old company, will it affect the approval of I-485?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
You would be relying upon a transfer of your case under I-485 J, which allows the labor certification and I-140 petition to remain valid if the I-140 petition is approved and the I-485 application pending 180 days, and the new job is in the same or similar occupation. Many factors are taken into account including job duties, SOC codes, job title, of which a $20,000 decrease is a factor to be looked at. It should be noted that $20,000 less when an individual is making a salary of $150,000 is less concerning than when the individual is making $50,000 or so under the labor certification.

3. Although your consulate office is listed in China, you may be able to have H-1B interview in Europe 

A reader asks:
Currently, I am in a small European country and plan to enter the United States to work in the near future. When the first H-1B visa address was chosen in China, there was a high probability that it would be checked. Considering that the current work is very tight and the check-in time is long, can the interview address be changed from China to the country where I currently am in Europe? Also can I get my passport back during the domestic visa interview?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
Even though you listed your consulate office as one in China when you filed your I-129 H-1B petition, you may be able to conduct your nonimmigrant visa interview in the European country that you are currently in. You may wish to check the consular post website to see whether it has guidance on its attitude toward third country nationals. If it accepts such cases or you are a resident in the European country, you can file a DS-160 with the European country after your H-1B petition is approved, and schedule an interview there. You may need to provide reasons why you are doing an H-1B interview in a third country rather than your home country–it is likely that a consular officer will be satisfied with your answer that you are currently living in that country and that it is much more convenient than going to China to conduct the interview. On your passport, a consular officer in this European country or China will take your passport to process the visa. The consulate may hold on to your passport for administrative processing if needed, but once a visa approval or denial is issued, you will have your passport returned.