Month: June 2024

1. I-485 has been submitted before being layoff, can apply for form I-765 

A reader asks:
I am in the central part of the country and have encountered layoffs. My current situation is that H-1B expires on July 30. RD is 173 days as of July 30th. It’s a bit hopeless to find a job in the next few days to renew the H-1B. I-485 has been submitted, but it has not been completed for 180 days. Some people say that as long as I am not scheduled for a green card interview during this period, I shall be safe. Is that so? Can I transfer into an F-1 and wait for green card? Or do I need to change jobs? or hope that my green card will be approved on July 30? Asked Emma, ​​said my case was in NBC for more information. PD is September 2019 and it is already current. If I find a job, do I need to submit H-1B and I-485J at the same time?

Mr. Alan Lee Esq. answers,
Generally, an employer sponsoring an applicant for I-140 and I-485 should have the intent to offer permanent employment at the time that the employer signs off on the I-140 and the I-485 J “Supplement J, Confirmation of Bona Fide Job Offer or Request for Job Portability under INA section 24 (J)”. If your I-485 pends for 180 days and you have a new employer in the same or similar occupation willing to continue your sponsorship and signs off on a new Supplement J, you can submit it to USCIS to attempt to port your employment to the new employer. In the meantime, you may consider applying for an EAD on form I-765 Application for Employment Authorization so that you can be available for employment with an employer other than your current one. Also you gave a certain date that your H-1B expires. Have you taken the 60-day grace period to find new employment into account? If you have a new employer willing to do so, it can also alternatively petition for a new H-1B on your behalf, preferably within the 60-day grace period.

2.  Withdrawal I-485 by mistake, attorney should rectify the situation as quickly as possible 

A reader asks:
I am currently preparing I-485 materials. Before my current company’s H-1B, a more complicated situation occurred. I would like to ask how to prepare the materials? The company made a personnel adjustment around April 2023, and I was not affected. However, the HR oolong put my name on the layoff list and sent it to the company’s lawyer to cancel the H-1B. The withdrawal application was submitted at that time. Later in September, I contacted the company’s lawyer. She realized that there was a problem before, so she quickly issued another H-1B application, added premium processing, and approved it quickly. The lawyer said that she was also applying to cancel the previous withdrawal application at the same time, so I now have two H-1B approval notices from the same company. According to the lawyer, the H-1B withdrawal application did not take effect, so there is no problem. Do I need to ask a lawyer for any documents to prove this? The I-485 documents only include the two H-1B approval notices. Do I need to submit documents for the application to revoke the H-1B and the subsequent revocation of the H-1B?

Mr. Alan Lee Esq. answers,
It appears that your company’s attorney attempted to rectify your situation as quickly as possible after you made her aware of the mistake. It is commendable that she was also attempting to cancel the previous cancellation notice to USCIS at the same time. On the I-485 application, it might be helpful to have the lawyer explain the entire sequence of events so that USCIS has a complete understanding of your situation prior to making an adjudication on your I-485 application. If possible, the lawyer can also use the opportunity to explain if and how you might still be eligible for I-485 adjustment even in the event that USCIS does revoke the first H-1B petition in April 2023.

3. Consular officers do keep historical records

A reader asks:
My status expired in 2018, so I had to apply for a dependent status. Later, I did not have a visa until my OPT expired. After moving to Canada, I was asked about the L visa, but I did not expect it and was not prepared, which led to the rejection of my visa in 2021. Now, more than a year has passed, and GK5 has passed. I want to try to go back with an L visa. However, because the L visa is valid for 5 years, the L visa I-797 used is still the same. I heard that in the United States, visa interviewers will not dig up such historical records after 5 years. Is this true? The last time my visa was rejected in 2021, I was asked about the rejection on the new DS160. Do I need to fill in the reason for the rejection directly? Is the specific explanation 212A6C? Or can it be said that I was not well prepared before?

Mr. Alan Lee Esq. answers,
Consular officers do keep historical records, and it is likely that your prior refusal will be on the database. You have said that the reason for rejection in the past was 212 A6C. That ground is inadmissibility for fraud or misrepresentation in attempting to enter the US. On the DS-160 nonimmigrant application form, there are two questions relevant to your situation – the first is, “Have you ever been refused a US visa, been refused admission to the United States, or withdrawn your application for admission at the point of entry? If yes, explain. When? Where? What type of visa?” and “Have you ever sought to obtain or assist others to obtain a visa, entry into the United States, or any other United States immigration benefit by fraud or willful misrepresentation or other unlawful means?”  To the first question, you would have to answer in the affirmative and answer the questions and state the circumstances that you believe are in your favor. If you believe that your explanation is thoroughly sufficient to explain that you did not commit fraud or misrepresentation, you may decide to answer “no” to the second question. The consular officer, however, should have a full understanding of the circumstances surrounding the prior denial when he or she finishes reading the DS-160 application.

4. It is not unusual that a principal applicant’s case will be adjudicated prior to that of the dependent

A reader asks:
I applied for EB-1B, and the waiting period has come. I just got my green card. My spouse and I submitted I-485, but it is still CRP. I would like to ask, is the subsequent review of the spouse’s status completely independent or will it have a certain impact?

Mr. Alan Lee Esq. answers,
A dependent spouse’s I-485 application is generally dependent upon the eligibility of the principal applicant, you. You have already received your green card, so that means that your principal case has been deemed approvable. The dependent will usually be approved if USCIS believes that the relationship is bona fide and that the dependent is not inadmissible to the US. Where marriages are concerned, USCIS may look into the marital relationship, especially if the couple married close to the time of submitting the I-485 applications. USCIS may also be conducting background clearances, and these are sometimes delayed. The agency wants to ascertain that applicants are not terrorists, have no criminal records or non-excludable criminal records, etc., before granting permanent residence. Dependents may also have had their own immigration file records in the past that USCIS will have to review before making a decision. It is not unusual that a principal applicant’s case will be adjudicated prior to that of the dependent.

1. You may be able to switch to the new job after 180 days of concurrently filing your I-140/I-485

A reader asks:
Currently, I have been in this company for many years and am somewhat underpaid. The salary is about 80% of the market rate. Fortunately, there is no risk of layoffs. I found a FAANG (5 high-tech companies – Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Google) job some time ago, and my salary was about 30% higher than my current salary. Should I submit the I-140 to this company first? How long does it take from application to approval?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
In this answer, I assume that your current company has a certified PERM labor certification application for you, and that it is eligible to submit an I-140 on your behalf. Since you are considering this FAANG position, I further assume that you have discussed the position with your prospective employer, and that it is willing to possibly sponsor you for PERM labor certification. A final assumption is that you will not be filing any employer-flexible employment-based petition such as EB-2 NIW or EB-1A. In your situation, you have a few options. First, you can ask your current employer file an I-140 for you and wait for it to be approved prior to transferring to the FAANG company. Of course, the caveat here is that the FAANG company may not still be willing to hire you after the time that the I-140 is approved or your employer may attempt to revoke the approval if it feel victimized by you. Additionally, in order to have employer-flexibility and “port” your job after filing your I-140, more conditions must be met. The I-140 must be approved or pending, and you must have an I-485 application that has been pending for at least 180 days. So for this to work ideally, your priority date should be current so that you can concurrently file the I-140 and the I-485. After this, you would be able to “port” your job after 180 days of filing your I-485 application to a same or similar job at the FAANG company. To complement this strategy, if your current employer agrees, you can file premium processing on your I-140 for an additional $2,805 so that you can be potentially have an approved I-140 after 15 business days. Without premium processing, an I-140 petition typically takes somewhere from 6 months to a year to adjudicate. In sum, under this strategy, you may be able to switch to the FAANG job after 180 days of concurrently filing your I-140/I-485, and not have to have the FAANG company do another PERM labor certification application on your behalf. Of course, if your priority date is not current, you will need to wait for it to become current until filing the I-485, and then wait 180 days thereafter to change jobs to the FAANG company via H-1B transfer or another legal mechanism. If your employer files an I-140 that is ultimately approved, but you are not able to file an I-485, you may at least be able to retain your priority date for a second employment-based immigrant petition.

Your second option is to just accept the FAANG offer, and do a work visa transfer to them without your current employer filing an I-140 on your behalf. The upside to this is that you will be able to accept the FAANG offer while it is still fresh and not risk that ship sailing. The downside is that you will forgo the PERM labor certification that your current employer has done for you, and have to redo the labor certification process with the FAANG company which will add approximately 2 years to your process (ETA 9141 currently taking 6-7 months to adjudicate and ETA 9089 over a year at this time). Unless you have an approved I-140 that has not been revoked by your previous employer, you will not be able to retain your old priority date either. Therefore, if you are willing to wait longer for your permanent residence while maintaining nonimmigrant status in the US and make more money in exchange, then this could be a viable option for you. 

2. If you are uncertain about your ability to obtain a renewed H-1B visa at your home consulate, having Advance Parole as a contingency plan could help

A reader asks:
I am EB-3, Form B is current this month, but Form A is not yet available. The lawyer now plans to submit I-485 and combo card applications at the same time, but I just returned to China last month to renew my H-1B stamp, and my H-1B visa (I-797) has also just been renewed for three years. I originally planned to go to Costarica for a vacation at the end of this year and return to China to visit my family in May next year, but now once the AP card application is submitted, I cannot leave the country. The lawyer said that it now takes about 12 to 15 months to get the AP card, which means that all overseas travel plans for next year (and maybe the year after) will be cancelled. Now, I want to tell the lawyer to only submit the I-485 and not submit the EAD and AP card applications, because considering that my H-1B stamp has one year to expire, the AP card will only be valid for 1 year even if I get it, and H- 1B visa stamp has about the same length of effect. In this case, I can return to my country with a valid visa next spring and wait until the visa stamp expires before applying for an AP card. Is it okay for me to think about it this way? My job is relatively stable. Although the salary is not high, I am not particularly worried about being laid off suddenly. If I don’t apply for an AP card now, will there be any other risks?

Arthur Lee Esq. answers,
While this is up to you, there is still some value in applying for the EAD & AP in your situation. The fact that you have fresh H-1B status with close to 3 years of validity is great in that it reduces the urgency in your situation to apply for an EAD and AP. You can freely travel back and forth on your H-1B visa as long as you are still employed at your H-1B sponsoring company or have a valid H-1B transfer petition approved. After your H-1B visa expires, you can renew at your home consulate when you return next Spring by applying for a DS-160 and having all necessary evidence available including your valid LCA, job letter from the company, and H-1B approval. Having an advance parole approved does not negate your H-1B visa. You can just use your H-1B visa to come in and out of the United States. Where the advance parole may benefit you is if your I-485 case takes more time to approve than the validity of your H-1B status. Of course, the advance parole is only valid for periods of to one year if not renewed. So you could consider applying for EAD & Advance Parole closer to the expiration of your H-1B if you so desire. If you wish to coordinate the advance parole with your H-1B status expiry, you could apply for the benefits about 12 months before the date of your H-1B expiration. Your I-485 case could possibly take longer to adjudicate than the validity of your H-1B status as employment-based cases in some jurisdictions are taking long to adjudicate—you can see the USCIS processing time charts for an approximate waiting time on your type of case—and because your priority date is not current with respect to the Final Action Dates (“Chart A”) yet. If your green card case is not approved yet, and you have an advance parole, you would generally be able to depart and enter the United States without needing to extend your H-1B status. Also, if you are for any reason uncertain about your ability to obtain a renewed H-1B visa at your home consulate, having Advance Parole as a contingency plan could help. While applying for I-485 without EAD or Advance Parole may work for you especially as you have nearly 3 years of H-1B validity, you may want to consider the above benefits and decide whether they are worth the extra applications to you. But aside from the costs, there are no perceptible downsides to applying for EAD and AP.

1. After filing form I-485, you are not allowed to leave the US without advance parole 

A reader asks:
I reviewed a copy of my filing papers today and I found two mistakes: 1. There were two addresses one in the United States and the other in China, both of addresses were put down as the present address. My lawyer discovered these problems before and I made the correction.  Unfortunately, the submitted paper was still incorrect. I worry it will affect my I-485 filing, and I must stay in the US for an RFE. 2. The preparer’s signature on the last page of I-485J was signed by my lawyer in 2022, while the previous pages were all dated 2023. I am going back to China next month, and I don’t know whether I should wait in China or not. At present, my lawyer has not responded to me whether it will have any impact. Please tell me, how deadly are the problems?

Alan Lee Esq. answers:
On your first mistake concerning your address on the I-485 application, USCIS will generally send all communications to both you and your attorney, and so if you do not receive a letter from USCIS, your lawyer will most likely inform you of its contents. I will also assume that USCIS believes that you are inside the United States since it did not reject the I-485 application, which can only be filed by individuals physically present in the country. On the second mistake of the I-485J signed by the lawyer in 2022, that is probably not a major problem as the signature date could have been a mistake. Otherwise, USCIS could RFE for a new form. Kindly note that after filing form I-485, you are not allowed to leave the US without advance parole unless on H-1B or L-1 visa.  If not in the 2 classes, leaving without an approved advance parole is grounds for canceling the I-485 application.

2. If you are not planning to immediately go to the US, don’t file EB-1A too early

A reader asks:
I am an associate professor in China, my job is ok, and I can apply for EB-1A, and I think I have a chance to get a green card. Even if I obtain a green card, I am unlikely to go to the United States immediately looking for a job, because my child is only 7 years old, and I plan for him to go to college in the future.  For my child, I want to apply for a green card. I would like to ask, is it too early to apply now?

Alan Lee Esq. answers:
The basis of all employment-based green card applications including EB-1A is that the individual will immigrate to use his or her talent and skill in this country. If you are not planning to immediately go to the US to find a position, then it would appear to be too early for you to apply for EB-1A status. Your concern appears to be your child going to college, and since most children here enter college around the age of 18, that is over 10 years according to your plan. An EB-1A case takes approximately 2-3 years if everything goes well, and so if you made the application now and are successful, you would have to figure out how to maintain your green card for 7-8 years before your child is of an age to enter college in the US.

3. B visa holders should be wary about submitting adjustment of status applications within 90 days of entering the US.

A reader asks:
B chart is current, but I am in mainland China. Does B1 visa holder must submit I-485 after 90 days of entering the United States? My lawyer told me that if the B chart was about to be closed, I could submit I-485 directly even it was within the 90 days period, and it should not be any problem. Will I-485 be approved only when the A chart is current?

Alan Lee answers:
Generally speaking, individuals on B visas should be wary about submitting adjustment of status applications within 90 days of entering the US. Although the 90-day rule has been largely disavowed, many immigration officers may believe the taking steps to submit I-485 applications within a short period of time of entering the States may be indicative of a misrepresentation at the time of entry that the individual had nonimmigrant intent to return to the home country. That being said, you may have misunderstood your lawyer and he or she may have considered the pros and cons and thought that in your case with Chart B of the visa bulletin (dates for filing chart) about to be closed, the better strategy would be for you to file even if within 90 days of entry. If you file for the adjustment of status before Chart B closes, you will have to wait until your priority date exceeds the date on Chart A (final action date chart) of the visa bulletin before your case can be approved.

4. If it has been more than 30 days since you received the email, and you have not yet received your receipt notice, you can request online

A reader asks:
I received an email reminder from the USCIS on January 17 that the filing fee and expedited money for my case have been deducted, but I have not yet received the receipt notice in the mail. The mailing address is the address of my house where my roommate has been. However, I have set up mail forwarding to forward emails to my wife. Now, neither side has received it. Is this normal?

Alan Lee Esq. answers:
I assume that by this time you have already received further word from USCIS, and that your question was sent within 2 weeks of you receiving the email from USCIS in January. If you have mail forwarding, the US Post Office forwards the mail to the location for forwarding. Although it does not forward certain documents from USCIS, it will generally forward a receipt. Please note that it takes time for USCIS to generate a physical receipt to send out, and it also takes the post office time to forward the mail. If it has been more than 30 days since you received the email, and you have not yet received your receipt notice, you can place an eRequest online at https://egov.uscis.gov/e-request/intro.do , then click on “did not receive notice by mail”. Go through the form, fill in all your needed information, and specify that you did not receive your receipt notice.  Hopefully, your situation will be resolved before you need to submit an eRequest, but by submitting an eRequest, you will alert USCIS that you still did not receive your notice.

5. For personal case inquiries, it is best to contact the USCIS Contact Center

A reader asked:
I am in China. About three or four years ago, I submitted I-140 at an immigration agency through a friend’s recommendation. I asked many times during this period, but the other party said that there was no result and it was still pending. I asked the other party for a receipt number, but they refused to give it. I suspected that it was never submitted. In the past few days, I asked the artificial Emma on the official website of the Immigration Bureau to check the receipt number. I changed to 4 different artificial Emmas and provided them with my name, birthday, mailing address etc. They all said that it could not be found in the system.  Is it possible to prove that it was not submitted? My friend said that since it has been submitted for so long, Emma should be able to find the receipt number through my information. Is this true?

Alan Lee Esq. answers:
Emma is not designed to locate applications or petitions for which there is no receipt. For personal case inquiries, it is best to contact the USCIS Contact Center telephonically at 1-800-375-5283 and explain your problem to the USCIS representative. I do note that contact representatives run the gamut from being very patient to impatient and that an impatient one may not be disposed to search the system to see whether a petition for you has been filed. Hopefully upon getting through, the representative will be helpful.