1. During your green card interview, it is a good idea to be forthcoming on the facts
A reader asks:
I am currently preparing the I-485, but there are some inconsistencies in my work experience in my past visa applications. I would like to get some opinions or suggestions. When I applied for a tourist visa in 2010, I filled in the name of my father’s company as my employer on the DS160 application form because I was actually working for an American company at that time. However, since this American company had no branches in China, it did not help me pay my pension insurance. Then I affiliated with my father’s company to pay my pension insurance. Later when I applied for an L-1 visa, I filled in that American company as my employer. Since then, whether it is H-1B visa, PERM or I-140 application, I have always truthfully filled in this American company as my work experience. Now I’m worried that USCIS will find this inconsistency when they review my I-485 petition. I would like to ask how to respond to this situation.
Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
In this answer, I will operate under the assumption that you answered Question #71 on the I-485 application: “Have you ever lied about, concealed, or misrepresented any information on an application or petition to obtain a visa, other documentation required for entry into the United States, admission to the United States, or any other kind of immigration benefit?” with the answer “no.” In such a case, a USCIS adjudicator may choose to overlook it as it was long ago, and you have been forthcoming with your applications and petitions ever since then, and have not had any issues to this date. Also, the adjudicator may think that such a misrepresentation was irrelevant to the visa issuance if the true facts had been known. On the other hand, a more stringent adjudicator may flag your misrepresentation as an issue—he/she may believe that you made a material misrepresentation in not listing an American company as your employer back in 2010 to increase your chances of being approved for a tourist visa. If asked about this during your green card interview, it is a good idea to be forthcoming on the facts. Some favorable factors to you may be that this misrepresentation was from over a decade ago; that you have been forthcoming on all of your applications since then; that ever since then you have dutifully maintained status and paid your taxes; that you left the United States before the conclusion of your B2 expiration during the trip in 2010; and that you are (presumably) otherwise approvable as a permanent resident. You may mention that you placed your father’s company down as your employer as that company paid your pension insurance, but the officer will likely find that irrelevant since you did not actually work at the company. By being forthcoming about the inconsistency here, the officer may decide to be lenient, and approve your I-485 anyway- especially if this inconsistency is the only red flag in your application, and if you come across as a well-mannered person of good moral character.
2. If you take a position in the Thousand Talents Program, you assume the risk of jeopardizing your immigrant visa application
A reader asks:
I joined a company after graduating with a PhD in biochemistry in the United States. After using up my OPT, I transferred to O1. I have been unsuccessful in applying for H-1B for many years and was recently laid off. Although I had expected it and had been looking for a new home for a long time, biotech has started to lay off a large number of employees since last year. It is difficult to find companies willing to run O1 in the capital market, and I am afraid that I will have to return to China as a last resort. Fortunately, NIW can come back after a few years of waiting. Now that I’m considering returning to China to work for a few years anyway, why not try to apply for a domestic talent introduction program? However, due to previous investigation of the Thousand Talents Program, I feel that these talent introduction programs are a bit sensitive, and I am worried it will affect the green card. I’m here to ask a lawyer for advice.
Arthur Lee Esq answers:
I would not generally recommend working for the Thousand Talents Program during your time waiting for your priority date to become current with respect to China EB-2 (I assume that your I-140 EB-2 NIW petition has been approved). While this may end up being a non-factor in your immigrant visa application when your priority date becomes current, it could very well jeopardize your application as export administration regulations are a point of emphasis for the US government now, especially toward Chinese nationals. While the Thousand Talents Program may be a legitimate program in China to encourage innovation in science and technology in China, law enforcement agencies in the U.S. and several other countries have raised concerns about the program as a vector for intellectual property theft and espionage. In your immigrant visa application, you will have to disclose that you worked for the Thousand Talents Program. This may invite significant scrutiny into your application. During your interview, you will need to make clear that while you worked in the Thousand Talents Program, you never committed IP theft or improperly gave trade secrets of U.S. organizations to China. The officer may ask you pointed questions regarding the work that you did with the Thousand Talents Program, and whether you have utilized knowledge attained in the U.S. (and the nature of the knowledge) to perform your tasks or worse, provided training based upon your knowledge gained in the U.S. Therefore, while the Thousand Talents Program may be your highest paying and most prestigious employment option while waiting in China, you assume the risk of jeopardizing your immigrant visa application if you take a position in such a program.
3. Is it considered fraud if submitting an I-485 application immediately after entering the country with a nonimmigrant visa?
A reader asks:
The main applicant F1 OPT recently submitted I-485 in the US, and his spouse in in China and plans to enter the country with an F2 visa in the near future. Please tell me does F2 have to wait 90 days after entering the country before submitting the I-485 application? It is said that submitting an I-485 application immediately after entering the country with a nonimmigrant visa is considered fraud. Does this also apply to F2? She had stayed in the US for several years on an F2 visa. She returned to China last year for business, and now she wants to come back and submit I-485.
Arthur Lee Esq. answers:
The question when filing the I-485 with respect to the previous entry is one of intent. Upon reviewing the entry preceding the I-485 application, a DHS adjudicator may seek to determine whether the applicant misrepresented his or her intent at the consulate when he or she applied for the nonimmigrant visa or upon entering the U.S. While the 90 day rule is no longer a rule but more of a guideline at this point, if somebody does something in the United States within the first 90 days of entry that contradicts the conditions of the visa, then a strict adjudicator may flag the case. In your case, if your spouse enters under an F2 visa, which has a nonimmigrant intent requirement, and files the I-485 shortly after entry, he or she may question your spouse’s original intent when entering the United States. It may be possible to successfully address such concerns and still be approved for permanent residence but be aware that her case could become problematic.