Article: WHERE ARE WE WITH FORMS I-485, I-539 AND I-765? DHS ORDERED TO TAKE BIOMETRICS OF DETAINED. EXORBITANT FINES FOR FAILURE TO DEPART RULED UNLAWFUL.

As published in the Immigration Daily on October 27, 2026

  1. Where are we with form I-485?

Viability of the current 9/18/26 edition of the I-485 form is dependent upon the result of litigation over the public charge rule as the form was updated to ask specific questions concerning “means tested public benefits” received instead of merely concentrating on the receipt of SSI and TANF (Temporary Assistance to Needy Families). Three cases are presently before Judge Ronnie Abrams of the Southern District of New York challenging the public charge rule – State of New York v. DHS, No. 26-cv-07978; City of New York v. DHS, No. 26-cv-07982; Make the Road New York v. DHS, No. 26-cv-08129. The parties appear to be moving on parallel tracks towards a merits determination in 2027 with no emergency requests for stay of the rule. So it appears that the current edition of the I-485 will remain in play for some time. An AILA (American Immigration Lawyers Association) practice alert notes the differing OMB expiration dates of the form – 10/31/27, 3/31/27, and 2/28/27 – and that the current date is 2/28/27. It has received reports of rejections which identify the OMB expiration date as the reason for the rejections. It appears obvious that such rejections are improper as an OMB expiration date should have no effect upon the acceptability of the form as long as the edition date is correct. USCIS should make this clear to all the service centers & lockboxes immediately if it has not already done so. Until there is further clarification, I-485 applicants should use the 9/18/26 edition with OMB expiration date 2/28/27.

  1. Where are we with forms I-539 and I-765?

These two forms’ edition dates also depend upon ongoing litigation. They are directly related to the F, I, J abolishment of duration of status rule that was to have come into effect on September 15, 2026, with both edition forms changing to 9/15/26. Instead, Massachusetts federal District Judge Dennis F Saylor in Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-13799 (D. Mass.), https://www.nafsa.org/sites/default/files/media/document/2026-09-14%20District%20Judge%20dckt%2050_0.pdf granted a nationwide preliminary injunction on September 14, 2026, blocking the rule from taking effect. The government then requested that district-court proceedings be stayed pending its appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, or alternatively that the district court establish an expedited schedule for further proceedings. The Court of Appeals set a briefing schedule on October 9 which will take at least 60 days for government brief, plaintiff response, and 10 days for reply. The District Court also took action on October 19 to expedite with November 2 set as the deadline for responsive briefing. In the meantime, USCIS will only accept the 8/28/24 edition of form I-539 and 8/21/25 edition of form I-765.

  1. DHS ordered to take biometrics of detained.

Detainees filing petitions or applications with USCIS have been unable to have their biometrics taken since December 2025 and had petitions or applications denied for the absence of biometrics. USCIS announced on December 5, 2025, that with the exception of applications and petitions filed with the Executive Office for Immigration Review, it would cease taking fingerprints and photos of those in custody. https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/alerts/uscis-updates-policy-on-biometrics-for-detainees. In the DC federal court, District Judge Amir H. Ali in J.Z et al. v. DHS, CIV 26-01510 (AHA) on October 7, 2026, blocked the government’s action in a memorandum opinion and order staying the new policy including the agency press release and policy alert, and implementing agency actions, including the policy manual revisions and rescission of the intra-departmental agreement requiring ICE to collect biometrics from detained people with pending USCIS applications. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/28731202-ali-biometric-data-order/ The government is to file a status report by October 21, 2026, apprising the court of compliance with the order. It should be noted that the plaintiffs moved for both a stay of the biometrics policy and a preliminary injunction, but the court did not grant the preliminary injunction saying that the plaintiffs had not shown that additional relief was necessary on the current record.

  1. Exorbitant fines for failure to depart ruled unlawful.

There is hope against these exorbitant fines up to $1.8 million for immigrants’ failure to depart after an order of removal.  In the US District Court in Massachusetts, Maria L & Nancy M v. Mullin, CIV 25-13471-GAO,  District Judge George O’Toole stayed the government’s use of exorbitant fines in an opinion and order on 9/30/26 (Nancy M being issued a fine of $1.82 million for her purportedly willful failure to depart even though she was in the country under an order of supervision). https://www.publicjustice.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/113-decision-and-order-granting-stay.pdf The court cited the government’s failure to give a period of notice and comment as the rule was promulgated as an interim final rule (IFR) and that there was no individualized assessment provided for whether the aliens’ failure to depart was willful or voluntary. Also to be noted is Northern California District Judge John Tigar’s 9/1/26 decision giving preliminary injunctive relief in Ye v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 4:26-cv-06417-JST (N.D. Cal.) to another individual assessed a $1.82 million fine in which the judge among other findings ruled that the fine fell within the excessive fines clause of the Eighth Amendment – that the civil penalties authorized by INA §274D are subject to the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition against excessive fines. https://docs.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/california/candce/4%3A2026cv06417/473067/36?utm_source=chatgpt.com. It remains to be seen what the future holds as DHS finalized the fine regulation on October 14 making a change from the interim final regulation with limited modification allowing late appeals due to mail delivery problems. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/06/27/2025-11965/imposition-and-collection-of-civil-penalties-for-certain-immigration-related-violations. It could argue that the comments considered between the IFR and final rule satisfy the requirement for notice and comment, but may continue to be hard-pressed to defend against plaintiffs’ multiple arguments that DHS must still establish the statutory element of willfulness; that a penalty remains subject to the excessive fines clause; that the agency must provide constitutionally adequate procedures; and that its determination must withstand arbitrary and capricious review under the Administrative Procedures Act.

Alan Lee, Esq. Q&As published on the World Journal Weekly on October 25, 2026: 1. If the petitioner is listed as an NIW company, you would need to port and file an I-485 J with a subsequent employer 2. Even if an I-140 petition is approved, it’s still possible to change to an F-1 visa 3. It’s best to withdraw the old petition before filing a new I-131

1. If the petitioner is listed as an NIW company, you would need to port and file an I-485 J with a subsequent employer

A reader asks:
My company will undergoing major changes soon, and next month my entire team will be laid off. I am exploring internal transfer. My NIW has already been approved, and my I-485 has been pending for three months; biometrics are done. However, when I applied for the NIW, it was directly related om my current team and the project I work on.  The new role I might transfer to will likely have nothing to do with the filed mentioned in my NIW.  If I transfer internally, I’m concerned that my NIW could be revoked, since it was handled by the company’s law firm. If I move to a new employer, I also worry that leaving my current employer could lead to NIW revocation. My questions: If I transfer internally to a new role and , unfortunate, I face a green card interview, could they question whether the new role matches my NIW filed and revoke it?  If I don’t transfer and instead get laid off, but claim that I’m still engaged in the NIW field during unemployment (just temporarily without a job), would that be risky? I have heard that for an I-485 filed through NIW, after 180 days pending, there’s no need to file an I-485J, and even if I’m unemployed at the 180-day mark, it won’t affect approval. Should I take the internal transfer? In this situation, what is my best choice?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
The initial question is whether the company’s law firm put down the company as the petitioner on the NIW petition. If so, you would still need to port and file an I-485 J with a subsequent employer after the adjustment application has been filed for 180 days to keep the petition. If you are both the petitioner and beneficiary, that is not necessary. In taking a new role with the company which is at odds with the NIW representations, the company would have to affirm at the time of your I-485 filing your position and salary, and if you are interviewed, you may be questioned concerning your NIW role. Between the choices of presenting yourself as unemployed and still being with the company, the better choice would probably be to stay with the company.

2. Even if an I-140 petition is approved, it’s still possible to change to an F-1 visa

A reader asks:
I currently have an approved I-140 for NIW, but my priority date is October 2023. If my H-1B is later laid off, is it still possible to convert to an F-1 visa? I’ve seen someone in a similar situation who seems to have successfully converted to an F-1. I also checked ChatGPT, and it said that the F-1 is a nonimmigrant visa, and the fact that the I-140 indicates immigrant intent might affect it. However, if you apply for a change of status within the US, your chances of approval might be higher. What advice does an attorney have?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
It may still be possible to switch over to F-1 visa status, especially on a change of status application within the US. Although there is the question of immigrant intent on the I-539 Application to Extend/Change Nonimmigrant Status, it has been our experience that USCIS may grant the change of status if there is a bona fide purpose and intent to the schooling and to leave the US after its end.

3. It’s best to withdraw the old petition before filing a new I-131

A reader asks:
My I-131 is at the MSC center and I don’t know when it will be approved, so I plan to use my H-1B visa to return to my home country for a trip. Technically, my I-131 will be denied for traveling abroad during its adjudication, but I’ve also seen cases where it was still approved.  If it is denied because I travel during adjudication, when will the denial status be updated? If, after reentering the U.S. with my H-1B visa, I immediately file a new I-131, do I need to proactively withdraw the old I-131?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
If you are using the H1B visa for reentry to the US after travel overseas, it may be in your best interest to withdraw the old I-131 filing to avoid a denial. It is hard to say when the denial will come, but it would probably be better to withdraw before filing a new I-131.

Alan Lee, Esq. Q&As published on the World Journal Weekly on October 4, 2026: 1. Problems with dependent applicant can affect the principal applicant 2. Holding a valid F-1 visa increases the chances of returning to the U.S.

1. Problems with dependent applicant can affect the principal applicant

A reader asks:
My spouse’s Chart A is current, so they can file an I-485 with their company. If I file my I-485 alongside with them, will my pending NIW I-140 affect either my spouse’s or my case? I’ve heard that if either the principal or the derivative has a pending I-140, there’s a high chance the case will go into a “black hole.” I am very worried. In this situation, what’s the best approach? Should I file my I-485 with my spouse while also applying for NIW premium processing? But I feel my case is weak, and will likely receive an RFE. I have two options:

  1. File my I-485 with my spouse and withdraw my NIW I-140.
  2. Apply for NIW premium processing, and if I get an RFE, withdraw my NIW, then file I-485 with with my spouse.

Which method is better?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
USCIS likes to adjudicate principal and dependent I-485 applications together, and if there are questions concerning a dependent, there is a chance that the principal’s application will be held up while USCIS does a file transfer for the dependent’s file and examines it for questions of inadmissibility or discrepancies with the I-485 filing. It is up to you as to whether to file and withdraw or withdraw after premium processing if there is an RFE and then file the I-485. If you believe that your case is weak, your first option may be the better one, but that of course is up to you.

2. Holding a valid F-1 visa increases the chances of returning to the U.S.

A reader asks:
I applied for OPT and during this period I also applied for a green card.  My current visa status is F-1. Before I get my I-140 approved can I return to my home country?

Alan Lee Esq. answers,
We give a general caution to nonimmigrants who wish to travel overseas that Customs and Border Protection (CBP) has been doing much heavier vetting of applicants for admission since Mr. Trump became president again. That being said, you have a fairly good chance of being able to return to the US if you have a valid F-1 visa in your passport. If you must see an American consular officer for a visa in order to return, there is a chance of it not being issued, especially if an I-140 petition has been filed even if not approved. It should also be noted that some consular officers are reluctant to issue F-1 visas for individuals on OPT.